Method
How the test works.
The book asks whether surviving evidence independently connects William Shakspere of Stratford to the literary activity credited to the name William Shakespeare, and it asks the same question, in the same words, of twenty-four other writers.
Two bodies of evidence
Parish, family, property, legal and testamentary records identify a historical person. Publications, literary commentary and theatrical attribution establish an authorial identity. The method, the Historical Literary Authorship Attribution Evidentiary Chain Method (HLAA–ECM), examines the two separately, so the identification can be tested without being assumed in the evidence offered to establish it. A connection between them may rest on one document or on several working together.
Three questions kept apart
| Question | What would answer it |
|---|---|
| Who is the historical person? | Identifying records whose force does not depend on assuming the literary attribution. |
| Is that person connected to literary activity? | Writing, literary service, a transaction or personally identifying testimony, supported directly or by complementary records. |
| Which works did that person substantially compose? | Evidence about composition and contribution to specified works. Personal literary activity alone does not settle a whole canon. |
Five questions for every record
- Namesake. Does the name refer to the right person?
- Role. Does the record show literary activity, rather than acting, ownership or proximity?
- Dependency. Are apparently separate witnesses repeating one source?
- Time. Does the connection originate during life, and when was it recorded?
- Authenticity. Is the document, hand or attribution sound enough to bear the inference?
These questions are not an invitation to doubt for its own sake. A merely imaginable namesake is not an objection, a well-supported catalog identification carries scholarly weight, and the strongest reasonable conventional reading is considered first.
The standard
Independent connection: a lifetime record connecting a recoverable historical individual to literary activity. It must be personal and discriminating, not impersonal or posthumous, and it must make the connection independently, not depend on the attribution being tested. The definition, term by term →
No document type is required: no autograph, payment, library or single self-sufficient record. The same small literary act that closes one writer's chain is all that is asked of any other.
What the findings mean
- Continuous: a direct or strongly combined connection survives without a material gap.
- Contingent: the pathway is thin or qualified; it may still establish the connection.
- Independently closed: the evidence establishes the connection without assuming the identity it is meant to establish.
- Independently unclosed: no qualifying connection has been established under the rules. This does not by itself establish that the person did not write.
Beaumont, Kyd and Webster are contingent but closed. Shakspere is contingent and unclosed.
Detection, falsification, explanation
The argument moves in three steps. Detection establishes the comparative pattern, following Diana Price. Falsification asks whether a qualifying lifetime connection should be expected, whether loss and later testimony can account for its absence, and whether the expectation survives seven tests: the seven gates. Explanation then asks what the record shows The Man did. An absence carries weight only where there is good reason to expect the evidence to have been made, kept and found.
Where to check the evidence
- Diana Price, Shakespeare's Unorthodox Biography: the comparative framework and her chart of literary paper trails.
- Catalogue of English Literary Manuscripts 1450–1700 (celm.folger.edu): manuscripts, hands and attributions.
- Shakespeare Documented (shakespearedocumented.folger.edu): the principal Shakespeare records.
- Lost Plays Database (lostplays.folger.edu) and the Henslowe papers: theatrical transactions.
- Every Authorship Chain on this site gives its archive and catalog references. All twenty-five →
- The Research Packet sets out the whole test so it can be repeated. Download it free →