The test · Prove me wrong

The test is public. Break it.

To keep the Stratford attribution, you must show that one of the seven gates is wrong, or produce the lifetime record the book says does not survive. Do either, and it will be reported here, at the top of this page, in full.

Findings changed by a challenge

None yet.

The rules

A challenge is answered when it can change something. These four rules make sure it can.

  1. 01Name your target. A gate, a definition, a document, or one writer's Authorship Chain.
  2. 02Say what it changes. Which gate falls, or which Authorship Chain opens or closes, and why.
  3. 03Cite a source anyone can check. A document, a catalog reference, a published edition.
  4. 04Argue the evidence, not the people. Motives, credentials and the author's identity are not challenges.

The seven gates

Select a gate to see what rejecting it would take.

What would change the result: Hand D securely his, showing composition or substantive revision; Chettle's subject securely identified; a warranted combined identification from the legal, company and Folio records; a control failing on full review; the difference vanishing under consistent rules; or new, securely identified literary evidence. Each, with its consequence →

Submit a challenge

Every challenge is read by B.I.G. The strongest are answered in the monthly public log; any that change a finding are reported at the top of this page. A pen name is welcome; this site would be in no position to object.

Standing invitations

The leading defenders of the Stratford attribution are invited, by name, to show where the test fails: here, in print, or in any public debate. Each argument is stated as its author made it. The reply is to the argument, never to the person.

Professor James Shapiro

Contested Will: Who Wrote Shakespeare? (2010)

The argumentThat the doubts arose from later assumptions about genius and autobiography, and that the documentary record (the title pages, Meres, Jonson, Sir George Buc's note, the testimony of colleagues) settles the question.

The gate it must defeatG5. Those sources secure the attribution, which the book grants in full. Buc's note reports who wrote another man's play; it records knowledge of provenance, not composing. Show which of them independently joins The Man to literary activity in his lifetime.

Sir Stanley Wells and Dr. Paul Edmondson

Shakespeare Beyond Doubt: Evidence, Argument, Controversy (2013)

The argumentThat the biographical, textual and bibliographical evidence, including every recorded reference to Shakespeare, puts his authorship beyond doubt.

The gate it must defeatG6. Counted once where they share a source, those references multiply the attribution rather than its independent foundations. Show one that independently identifies The Stratford Man as composing, from his lifetime.

Sir Jonathan Bate

The Genius of Shakespeare (1997) and later essays and debates

The argumentThat his contemporaries knew him and spoke of him as a writer, and that no one in his lifetime doubted his authorship.

The gate it must defeatG1. Grant every contemporary reference, as the book does: a lifetime record that independently connects The Man to the writing is still missing. And the period was not silent on borrowed credit: Greene's “upstart Crow” and Davies's “English Terence” are weighed in the book. Show the record, or show why none should be expected.

Each will be answered in full in a Replies to critics Dispatch. Any reply received is published here, with B.I.G.'s answer.

The public log

MonthChallengeTargetStatus
At launchThe first log is published one month after launch.——

STATUS KEY: ANSWERED · UNDER REVIEW · CHANGED A FINDING