For scholars · The Research Packet

Check it. Repeat it. Overturn it.

Something Rotten: Research Packet for Scholarly Review is the complete reproducibility package for the book. The book states the argument; the packet shows the work, step by step, with every source and locator, so that any reader can reach their own verdict.

Download the Research Packet (PDF)

Free · no sign-up · 18 pages · PDF · Version 1.0, 19 November 2026

What is inside

  1. The claim, and what is not claimed. The hypothesis tested, the identity grant, and the limits of the finding.
  2. The standard and the five tests. Namesake, role, dependency, temporal, authenticity: applied to every case.
  3. Detection. The finding for all twenty-five, and why the Stratford chain does not close, source by source.
  4. Falsification. Expectation, loss, testimony, and the seven rejection gates with the strongest adverse point against each.
  5. What would change the finding. Six named discoveries, Hand D first.
  6. How to repeat the test. Seven steps, and where to start.
  7. Disclosed limits. Stated so reviewers know where to direct their scrutiny.
  8. Annex A. The chain for each writer, with archive and catalog references. Also on this site →
  9. Annex B. Further lifetime items a reviewer will raise, and why none closes the chain.
  10. Annex C. The reviewer form: one per case.
  11. Annex D. Why Fletcher closes and Stratford does not, step by step.
  12. Annex E. Diana Price's chart of literary paper trails.

Then try to break it

Start with the thinnest cases: Webster, Kyd, Beaumont, Fletcher, Marlowe, Watson and Stratford. Fill in the reviewer form in Annex C for each case you test, and do not copy the author's judgment.

If your verdict differs, send it with the source and your reasoning. The strongest challenges are answered in public.

Prove me wrong

Citing the packet

Baxter Isaac Grey, Something Rotten: Research Packet for Scholarly Review, version 1.0 (19 November 2026), https://somethingrotteninstratford.com/research-packet/.

If a finding or a source is corrected, a new numbered, dated version will replace this file, and the correction will be recorded on Prove Me Wrong. To hear about corrections and new Dispatches, get notified.